- "He looks like a sweet guy to spend time with, he's got a nice smile, but what he's saying is so odious it makes me want to napalm his mouth."
- —Howard Bloom on Brother Nathanael.
Nathanael used to be a filthy Jewish cockroach before he fully cleansed himself of the kosher evilness and is now a child of Jesus, even though he still looks and talks like a caricature of a rabbi. He was raised in an existence of wickedness and reprobation, but currently lives a fulfilling life posting YouTube videos exposing the Jewish conspiracy outside a local ski park while showcasing his contemporary dance skills at the same time.
He was first seen in Episode 63 when he claimed he had revealed a "Jewish plot" to make 'Murica gay. He appeared again in Episode 129 following the Jewish-organized legislation of same-sex marriage on a federal level and how marriage is between one man and one woman blah blah blah sodomy blah blah blah blah babies blah blah blah friendly fag. He appeared once more in Episode 135 where he talked about the Iran Deal. He later appeared in Episode 149, talking about how he would punish the Jews if he was the president.
He reappeared in Episode 156.
- Nathaniel's parents were Jewish sum, and he was also originally a Jew.
- He strongly resembles Dr. Gero from Fire Ball Z.
- He apparently has the power to disappear into thin air.
- He is Father Grigori's retarded brother (without the awesome Winchester skills as well).
- He did 9/11.
- He's one of the only people featured on DP that actually has the balls/guts/hatred/lack of filter and, or shame or chutzpah to use the word "fag" as an actual derogatory slur.
- According to Ben, he actually was Jewish during some part of his life.
- He looks like Jinpachi Mishima from Tekken.